Commenting on other people’s blogs

Because Ms McArdle’s comment system seems to be a bit broken, I will have to do my commenting here, although – alas – I fear this means at least a three-orders-of-magnitude drop in the number of people who see my deathless prose and sparkling wit. At any rate, I’d like to point out that this:

Who am I to say that your life is not better with a sports car and five years to live? And to the former argument, I point out that in fact, you’ll probably end up giving the wastrels less money if they do fritter it away. Because once you’ve actually provided people a minimum income that is adequate to take care of their basic needs, there’s no moral reason not to turn away those who decline insurance from the emergency rooms. Giving people more choices also means allowing them to live with the consequences of those choices.

is just a bit over-optimistic, to say the least. How are we going to credibly commit to turning people away from emergency rooms? Just who are we going to hire for the job of looking at the victim of a car accident – bleeding to death, perhaps, but with enough awareness to plead for her life – and say “Sorry, you’re not insured, out you go”? Even TSA’s goons, notoriously a joyless and robotic bunch, might balk at the task. Not to mention the uproar there would be the day after. How many headlines of an “X died for lack of Y dollars of emergency care” or “Turned out to die, would have cost $500 to save” nature would it take to overthrow this system? And this is true even though Ms McArdle’s point about moral obligations is perfectly valid. Humans just don’t seem to be wired to let people lie in the beds they make for themselves, if those beds are sufficiently uncomfortable.



Filed under Economics

4 responses to “Commenting on other people’s blogs

  1. Richard Campbell

    I think you’re overestimating how many people read the comments on Megan McArdle’s blog.

    From what I recall based on my sporadic attempts to read them, said comments are a write-only function, more akin to stuffing a message in a bottle and tossing it into the ocean than engaging in a dialogue.

  2. kingofmen

    Well, if I had ~50 comments per post, I think I would not read them as carefully as I do now, or respond individually, either. There does seem to be a thriving commenter community, which presumably reads the comments, even if the blogger herself doesn’t.

  3. Carillon

    On a related note, can I change that little face thing that shows up?

  4. kingofmen

    I think you can upload an avatar if you have an account, which is free. Otherwise it’s auto-generated from your email. So you could change your email at random and see what happens. :p

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s